Meiselman, Denlea, Packman, Carton & Eberz P.C., Attorneys at Law

Jacoby & Meyers Federal Actions

C L A S S   A C T I O N   R E P O R T E R

Tuesday, May 24, 2011, Vol. 13, No. 101

Headlines

* Jacoby & Meyers Files Class Actions v. NJ, Ct. & NY Justices
--------------------------------------------------------------

Cheryl Armstrong at Courthouse News Service reports that personal injury powerhouse Jacoby & Meyers filed federal class actions against the justices of courts in New Jersey, Connecticut and New York, challenging what the firm calls an "antiquated" state ethics law that forbids lawyers from practicing in firms that are at least partly owned by nonlawyers.

Rule 5.4 of the state's Rules of Professional Conduct "is impeding law firms' ability to compete in today's global marketplace and restricting the public's access to affordable, quality representation," according to the complaint.

The self-proclaimed "pioneers" of "legal services for the masses" say this restriction unconstitutionally blocks them, and other lawyers, from exchanging a stake of their firms for capital.

Ultimately, they say, the public has to foot the bill since the restriction "dramatically impedes access to legal services for those otherwise unable to afford them."

"As a result, critical sources of funding are unavailable to a majority of lawyers in New Jersey (and elsewhere) which dramatically impedes access to legal service for those otherwise unable to afford them," according to the complaint.

"By this action, Jacoby & Meyers seeks to free itself of the shackles that currently encumber its ability to raise outside financing and to ensure that American law firms are able to compete on the global stage," the 23-page complaint also states.

Jacoby & Meyers is a New York-based firm of nearly 100 employees with two offices in New Jersey.

The class seeks an injunction and an order declaring that the ethics rule violates the federal and state constitutions.

"The present system perpetuates economic inequity at every level of practice," Jacoby & Meyers claims.  "The small practice does not have access to the capital markets that the Wall Street firms have and the Wall Street firms do not have access to the funding sources that firms in the U.K. and Australia have."

In the U.K. and Australia, law firms are allowed to benefit from nonlawyer equity, while the District of Columbia allows nonlawyers to own up to 25% interest in a firm, according to the complaint.

While law firms have generally "self-financed their operations through capital contributions, cash flow and bank loans," law firms today need a new revenue source, according to the complaint.

"In these challenging economic times, these 'normal' channels for capital infusion are either too expensive or unavailable to fund Jacoby & Meyers' intended business plans," the firm says.

Without a "substantial infusion of new capital," Jacoby & Meyers will have to put the kibosh on plans to hire more staff, improve its offices and expand "within communities in which working-class, blue-collar and immigrant families reside."

Noting that critics say nonlawyer investments will lead to "the violation of clients' confidences, the erosion of lawyers' independent judgment and the specter of a loss of professionalism," Jacoby & Meyers calls such fears unsubstantiated.

"There are innumerable ways in which to ensure that a lawyer's professional 'independence of judgment' remains resolute," according to the complaint.

Jacoby & Meyers, a New York-based firm of nearly 100 employees, has two offices in New Jersey.  It rose to prominence after airing the nation's first television commercial advertising legal services in the country.

The class seeks an injunction and an order declaring that the ethics rule violates the federal and state constitutions.

Jacoby & Meyers made the same allegations against the judges of the Connecticut Superior Court and the justices of New York state courts.

A copy of the Complaint in Jacoby & Meyers Law Offices, LLP v. The Justices of the Supreme Court of New Jersey, Case No. 11-cv-_____, docketed as Doc. 11707 in Case No 33-av-00001 on May 18, 2011 (D. N.J.), is available at http://is.gd/yoTG53

The Plaintiff is represented by:

David J. Meiselman, Esq.
James R. Denlea, Esq.
Jeffrey I. Carton, Esq.
Barry B. Cepelewicz, Esq.
MEISELMAN, DENLEA, PACKMAN, CARTON & EBERZ P.C.
1311 Mamaroneck Avenue
White Plains, NY 10605
Telephone: (914) 517-5000


*********

S U B S C R I P T I O N   I N F O R M A T I O N

Class Action Reporter is a daily newsletter, co-published by Bankruptcy Creditors' Service, Inc., Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania, USA, and Beard Group, Inc., Frederick, Maryland USA.  Leah Felisilda, Noemi Irene A. Adala, Rousel Elaine Fernandez, Joy A. Agravante, Ronald Sy, Julie Anne Lopez, Christopher Patalinghug, Frauline Abangan and Peter A. Chapman, Editors.

Copyright 2011.  All rights reserved.  ISSN 1525-2272.

This material is copyrighted and any commercial use, resale or publication in any form (including e-mail forwarding, electronic re-mailing and photocopying) is strictly prohibited without prior written permission of the publishers.

Information contained herein is obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed.

The CAR subscription rate is $575 for six months delivered via e-mail.  Additional e-mail subscriptions for members of the same firm for the term of the initial subscription or balance thereof are $25 each.  For subscription information, contact Christopher Beard at 240/629-3300.

* * *  End of Transmission  * * *

Wall Street Journal Article (pdf)

www.legalaccessforall.org/

https://www.facebook.com/pages/New-York-NY/Legal-Access-for-All/162923723770622#!/pages/New-York-NY/Legal-Access-for-All/162923723770622?sk=wall

http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2011/05/19/lawsuits-seek-to-open-up-the-legal-biz/?KEYWORDS=Jacoby

https://www.facebook.com/pages/New-York-NY/Legal-Access-for-All/162923723770622#!/pages/New-York-NY/Legal-Access-for-All/162923723770622?sk=wall

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In
Jacoby & Meyers, a pioneer of television legal advertising, filed lawsuits Wednesday challenging ...
http://www.businessinsider.com/jacoby-and-meyers-fights-to-let-nonlawyers-buy-in-2011-5

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In | PinkChipStocks.com
Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In BY NATHAN KOPPEL Jacoby & Meyers Law Offices LLP, a pioneer of television legal advertisi...
pinkchipstocks.com/jacoby-meyers-fights-to-let-nonlawyers-b...

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In
By Nathan Koppel Jacoby & Meyers Law Offices LLP, a pioneer of television legal advertising, filed lawsuits Wednesday challenging state laws in New York, ...
billionaires.forbes.com/article/01Eqfs31cHgUf?q=Wall...

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In | WOPULAR
Jacoby & Meyers, a pioneer of television legal advertising, filed lawsuits Wednesday challenging state laws in New York, New Jersey and Connecticut that ...
http://www.wopular.com/jacoby-meyers-fights-let-nonlawyers-buy-1

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In - Business Exchange
BX Home · Business Ethics; Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In. Join Business Exchange to access the most relevant content for you, ...
bx.businessweek.com/.../2022221589504480325-daf475d635...

Jacoby & Meyers' lawsuit challenges the legal establishment
Jacoby & Meyers Law Offices LLP, a pioneer of television legal advertising, filed lawsuits Wednesday challenging state laws in New York, New Jersey and ...
mma.msg.com/article/0147f175XUepY?q=Connecticut

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In - WSJ.com ...
Jacoby & Meyers sues to end laws stopping nonlawyers from owning law firms http //j.mp/jPzdNU #biglaw #law. by Dennis Berman, Columnist and Deputy Bureau ...
muckrack.com/link/5235521

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In
Dow Jones Reprints: This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, ...
billionaires.forbes.com/article/0dgL6jc6tV5K7

Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy - One News Page Business
Jacoby & Meyers Fights to Let Nonlawyers Buy In: Jacoby & Meyers, a pioneer of television legal advertising, filed lawsuits Wednesday challenging.
http://www.onenewspage.com/news/Business/20110518/22404283/Jacoby-Meyers-Fights-to-Let-Nonlawyers-Buy.htm

Social Network
dkberman Most impt. lawsuit of the year! Jacoby & Meyers sues to end laws stopping nonlawyers from owning law firms http://j.mp/jPzdNU #biglaw #law ...
matchfriends.org/twitter_timeline_public.php?q=%23BigLaw

 

Firm Selected to Best Lawyers in America

The firm is honored to have been recognized by its peers for inclusion in the 2012 edition of the US News and World Report's "Best Law Firms in America".

Two Partners Selected as Fellows of the American Bar Foundation

The firm is pleased to announce that David Meiselman and Jeff Carton have been invited to become Fellows of the American Bar Foundation.

MDPCE Prevails on a Summary Judgment Motion

The firm recently won a summary judgment motion in a case venued in Mercer County, New Jersey.

HHS Announces Final Rule to Incentivize Physicians and Others to Join ACOS

The proposed rule relating to Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) was, at best, difficult to understand, and, at worst, created another concern physicians had to face in determining whether they were going to survive as businesses.

Physicians Face Severe Medicare Cuts

The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), which is responsible for advising Congress on Medicare pay rates, has proposed a plan on October 6 recommending a 10-year freeze for primary care physicians and significant pay cuts to specialists.

Five Attorneys Selected as New York "Super Lawyers" -- Two Named to Top 25 in Westchester

"The New York Times" and "Westchester Magazine" recently published the list of 2011 New York "Super Lawyers" and the firm is honored to have five of its partners named to the list.

Firm Presents Webinar for Association of Corporate Counsel ("ACC")

On September 20, 2011, Jeff Carton and Joanna Sandolo presented a Webinar on "The Rights of Publicity" for the ACC's Sports & Entertainment Interest Group.

MDPCE Retained as General Counsel for the Connecticut Orthopaedic Society

We are pleased to announce that Meisleman, Denlea, Packman, Carton & Eberz P.C. has been retained as General Counsel for the Connecticut Orthopaedic Society. We look forward to working with the Society and its members to further their aspirations professionally and personally.

Jacoby & Meyers Fights To Permit Private Funding Of Law Firms

On May 18, 2011, MDPCE filed ground-breaking lawsuits, seeking to permit private funding for law firms.

Webinar

On April 13, 2011 David J. Meiselman, James R. Denlea and Barry B. Cepelewicz presented a webinar entitled "How to Protect Your Medical Practice and Make it More Profitable in Today's Volatile Climate."

MDPCE Files Class Action Against AAA Southern New England

The firm has filed a class action lawsuit alleging a deceptive business practice by the AAA affiliate for Southern New England.

Barry Cepelewicz Spoke At Connecticut Orthopaedic Society Dinner

On January 6, Barry Cepelewicz, M.D., J.D. presented "Contracting Issues: Concerns and Opportunities"

Appellate Division Dismisses Claim Against Hudson Valley Doctor

In a recent case argued before the Appellate Court by Richard J. Nealon, a member of the firm, we were recently successful in overturning a trial court decision allowing a plaintiff to pursue a claim that a Hudson Valley primary care physician was liable solely for converting his pen and ink records to electronic media.

MDPCE Prevails On Summary Judgment Motion

The firm recently prevailed on a summary judgment motion, winning the dismissal of a negligence case against our client.

Firm Prevails On Summary Judgment Motion

MDPCE recently prevailed on a motion for summary judgment in a case venued in Orange County, New York.

Barry B. Cepelewicz, M.D., Esq. Spoke At FCMA Event

On Thursday, December 9, 2010, Dr. Cepelewicz presented "Evaluating Your Medicare 2011 Participation Options" at The Waters Edge at Giovanni's in Darien, Connecticut.

MDPCE Wins Again!

We recently prevailed in a dental malpractice case, after a two-week trial.

Barry B. Cepelewicz, M.D., Esq. Spoke at FCMA Event

On October 20, Dr. Cepelewicz presented "Managed Care Contract Negotiations" at The Doubletree Hotel in Norwalk, Connecticut.

New Jersey Supreme Court Unanimously Reverses Lower Courts' Decisions

After a lengthy battle in the lower courts, the New Jersey Supreme Court issued a landmark decision certifying a consumer fraud class action to proceed against Carter-Reed. Co. and others concerning the purported belly-fat reduction pill Relacore.

Another MDPCE Win!

The firm recently prevailed on behalf of its clients after a two week jury trial.

MDPCE Appellate Expertise

Myra Packman has been called upon again as outside appellate counsel to two trial firms who had obtained adverse results for their clients.

Barry Cepelewicz, M.D., Esq. Spoke at FCMA Event

Meiselman Denlea is General Counsel to the Fairfield County Medical Association (FCMA).

MDPCE Continues Its Vigorous Representation of Physicians

MDPCE has been retained to represent various physicians and medical groups against allegations of medical malpractice.

Firm Growth Continues

We are pleased to announce the addition of three outstanding attorneys to our firm.

Westchester Magazine Features New York "Super Lawyers"

Super Lawyers 2010
Six Partners Honored As Distinguished Practitioners. Congratulations to our litigation partner Jeff Carton for being recognized as one of Westchester County's Top 25 "Super Lawyers."

MDPCE Wins in Arbitration Proceeding

MDPCE represents an internationally renowned author, advisor, trader, and entrepreneur who speaks and teaches on trading financial instruments for a living.

Complex Commercial Case Against Major National Bank

MDPCE is prosecuting a complex commercial case against a major national bank. The suit was brought on behalf of a family trust that sustained multi-million-dollar losses in an extraordinarily complex and highly leveraged transaction.

Major Metropolitan Hospital Sued for Aids Phobia

The law firm was recently retained by a major metropolitan hospital to defend it against allegations of "Aids Phobia".

Firm Secures Costco Class Action Settlement

In April 2010, MDPCE won Federal Court approval of a multi-million dollar class action settlement against Costco Wholesale Corp. The firm challenged Costco's policy of backdating membership renewals.

Appellate Division Sustains Dismissal of Claims Against Defendant Thoracic Surgeon

Plaintiff, a 54 year-old female, sustained a brachial plexus injury in the course of a right upper lobectomy for bronchogenic carcinoma.

Trident Xtra Care Consumers File Class Action

Cadbury Adams USA, LLC, the maker of Trident chewing gums, represents that its Trident Xtra Care chewing gum "Strengthens and Rebuilds Teeth".

Kroger Class Action Regarding Glucosamine

The firm recently commenced in Orange County, California a consumer fraud, class action lawsuit challenging Kroger's sale of a Glucosamine supplement which can allegedly "help build cartilage."

Samsung's Misleading Advertising Challenged

The firm recently commenced an action in federal court in New Jersey, challenging Samsung's misleading advertising of its line of "LED" flat screen televisions separate and apart from the conventional LCD or plasma technology by which flat screen televisions are typically grouped.

Dutchess County Supreme Court Dismisses Case Against Radiologist Charged With Failing To Read Mammogram Properly

The Supreme Court, Dutchess County recently dismissed all claims against a radiologist charged with failing to read the plaintiff's mammogram properly.

Appellate Division Sustains Orders Regarding Propriety of Service

On March 9, 2010, the Appellate Division, Second Department affirmed a trial decision denying dismissal and granting the firm's cross-motion to extend time to serve an estate.

Sony Playstation 3 Consumers File Nationwide Class Action

The firm has filed a lawsuit against Sony Computer Entertainment America, Inc., for Sony's decision to force users of its Playstation 3 console to either install an update that would disable the console's "Other OS" feature or lose the ability to play games with other users in the network.

David Meiselman and Barry Cepelewicz Speak At FCMA Event

Meiselman Denlea, General Counsel to the Fairfield County Medical Association (FCMA) offers educational seminars to physicians on how to protect their practices from liability and increase their practices' profitability.

Emailing Patients? BE CAREFUL

By: Barry B. Cepelewicz, M.D., Esq.

Effective Use of Physician Assistants

By: Barry B. Cepelewicz, M.D., Esq. and Richard J. Nealon, Esq.

Firm To Prosecute Birth Control Products Yaz, Yasmine and Ocella

The Firm is currently preparing to prosecute more than two dozen personal injury mass tort matters involving the birth control products Yaz, Yazmine and the generic version named Ocella.

Appellate Division Upholds Firm's Victory

The New York Appellate Division, Second Department, has affirmed the dismissal of a fraud case brought against our clients, a corporation and its individual owners.

Firm Secures Dismissal of Marina in Premises Liability Action

The New Jersey Supreme Court has declined to hear an appeal in a case in which the Firm won summary judgment for its client, thereby sealing the Firm's victory in this case.

MDPCE Appointed to Executive Committee Leading National Consumer Fraud Action

MDPCE has been appointed to the Executive Committee responsible for prosecuting the nationwide consumer fraud class action litigation concerning the deceptive sales practices committed by Bayer Healthcare LLC.

MDPCE Leads National Class Action

MDPCE has been appointed co-lead counsel by the federal judge overseeing the nationwide, consumer fraud litigation against Ticketmaster and TicketsNow.com alleging that defendants' deceptive practices misled consumers into paying well above face value for tickets when tickets were available at face value.

3 Chosen to Elite Lawyers of America

David Meiselman, Jim Denlea, and Jeff Carton have been selected as Members of the Elite Lawyers of America ("ELA").

David Meiselman and Barry Cepelewicz Speak at FCMA Events

Meiselman Denlea, General Counsel to the Fairfield County Medical Association (FCMA), offers educational seminars to physicians on how to protect their practices from liability and increase their practices' profitability.

Jeffrey Carton Selected to Become a Fellow in Trial Lawyer Honorary Society

Jeffrey Carton has been selected by the Advisory Board of the Litigation Counsel of America ("LCA") to become a Fellow in this Trial Lawyer Honorary Society.

Protect Your Company Against False Claims Act Lawsuits

Despite the economic crisis that is plaguing corporate America, the United States government continues to earn significant revenues from prosecuting False Claims Act or Qui Tam litigation.

David Meiselman, James Denlea, and Jeffrey Carton Selected to 2009 "Super Lawyers"

Super Lawyers 2009
Congratulations to our partners David J. Meiselman, James R. Denlea, and Jeffrey I. Carton who have been selected to be included in the 2009 Corporate Counsel Edition of "Super Lawyers".

Radiologists: Beware of the Revised Anti-Markup Rule!

On January 1, 2009, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' ("CMS") revised anti-markup rule went into effect. The revised rule prohibits the markup of the professional component (PC) and/or technical component (TC) of a diagnostic test when the billing physician does not share a practice with the physician providing the test.

Successfully Defending Copyright Infringement Suits

By: David J. Meiselman and Jeffrey I. Carton Published in the Metropolitan Corporate Counsel, February 2009

MDPCE Presents at The 217th Annual Meeting of the Fairfield County Medical Association

Thursday, April 30, 2009 Trumbull Marriot Hotel 180 Hawley Lane Trumbull, Connecticut

How To Litigate Successfully: A Five-Part Series

By: David Meiselman and Jeffrey Carton, Esq.

Appellate Division Sustains Gift Card Class Action Against Shell Oil

MDPCE recently prevailed in the New York State Appellate Division, Second Department in obtaining a reversal of a trial court's order dismissing a class action complaint against Shell Oil.

David Meiselman, James Denlea, Myra Packman, Jeffrey Carton and James Eberz Selected to 2008 "Super Lawyers"

Super Lawyers 2008
Congratulations to our partners David J. Meiselman, James R. Denlea, Myra I. Packman, Jeffrey I. Carton and James G. Eberz

Federal Court Certifies to Proceed on Behalf of Nationwide Class of Hollywood Tans' Consumers

On August 11, 2008, the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey granted the Firm's motion for class certification, paving the way for the firm to represent hundreds of thousands

Lending Tree Sued for Exposing Customers to Fraud and Identity Theft

NEW YORK (May 20, 2008): Millions of customers have been potentially exposed to fraud and identity theft by the nation's largest online lending institution, Lending Tree, LLC, according to a class action lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court.

MDPCE Wins Reversal of $3.2M Judgment in U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

MDPCE was successful in obtaining reversal of a judgment entered against our physician client in the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, The Top Trial Lawyers in America, Inducts 3 Partners

David Meiselman, James Denlea, and Jeff Carton have each been inducted into the prestigious Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum

David Meiselman, Myra Packman and James Eberz Selected to "Best Lawyers"

Congratulations to our partners, David J. Meiselman, Myra I. Packman, and James G. Eberz

MDPCE Wins $4.5M Lawsuit Against RPI Contractor

Electrician sued after suffering serious injuries while on a high-voltage repair job at campus research center.

A New Battleground for Class Action War

By: Jeffrey I. Carton, Esq. Published in the New York Law Journal October 10, 2006

Firm Handles Acquisition of $27 Million Office Complex

Class A White Plans Office Space Acquired By Core Plus Properties

National Consumer Class Action Suit Filed Against Diet Supplement Cortislim

Orange County, CA suit charges manufacturer with false, deceptive and unsubstantiated advertising claims
     
©2003-2012
Disclaimer and Credits
Meiselman, Denlea, Packman, Carton & Eberz P.C.
Attorneys at Law
1311 Mamaroneck Avenue
White Plains, NY 10605
Tel: (914) 517-5000